|
In
1990, a group of scientists concerned about the implications of
the unigender model of scientific inquiry founded the Society
for the Advancement of Womens Health Research (SAWHR) to
bring attention to the scientific weaknesses caused by the exclusion
of women <as subjects>from clinical research. By 1995, Dr.
Florence Haseltine of the NIH and co-founder of SAWHR, had coined
the term gender-based
biology. Reports submitted by more than 50 different research
organizations for SAWHRs November 1998 annual Scientific
Advisory Meeting in Washington,DC provide some answers in the
examination of differences between genders in a cell, organ, or
individual towards an understanding of the what the differences
tell us about the system in which they function. Symptoms of disease,
mechanisms of disease, and responses to treatment differ between
women and men. Excerpted from their summary report are several
thought-provoking findings and opportunities for cross-discipline
research reprinted below. Full copies of the research findings
are available at www.womens-health.org.
How
are the human genetics of obesity influenced by gender? Women
have approx. 40% higher levels of leptin, the product of the ob
gene, than men do, which does not appear to be due to reproductive
hormone differences. A rodent model of obesity shows that female
Zucker rats, which are heterozygous for the fatty (fa) gene have
a survival advantage early in life compared to those that do not
carry the gene. However, this effect is not observed in male rats.
These findings may explain the survival of obesity genes in the
population and provide another example of gender-based biological
differences in obesity.
Lung
cancer is the number one cancer killer in women, followed by breast
cancer and colorectal cancer. Given the same level of lifetime
exposure to cigarette smoke, the risk for developing lung cancer
is 20% to 70% higher in women than men at every level of exposure
to cigarette smoke, indicating that women are more susceptible
to the carcinogens in cigarettes. In fact, women with a shorter
smoking history than men appear to be at increased risk for lung
cancer. This is despite the facts that women tend to smoke lower
tar and nicotine cigarettes than men, and that women smokers,
on average, inhale less deeply than men do. Women who smoke have
a higher level of specific DNA adducts than do men, indicating
a higher risk of lung cancer in women with similar levels of smoking.
Cardiovascular disease remains the number one cause of death in
the United States and the leading killer of women, causing nearly
half of all deaths in women.
Research findings indicate differences in the regulation of heart
muscle growth and vascular structure between men and women. Angiotensin
converting enzyme (ACE) generates angiotensin II, a small hormone
with several functions in the cardiovascular system, including
regulating blood pressure and cell growth. In men, alterations
in the ace gene are associated with an increase in cardiovascular
risk, in particular an increase in the size of the heart. The
same genetic alterations in women, however, are not associated
with increased cardiovascular risk. Despite the numerous roles
of estrogen in cardiovascular health, data from the Heart and
Estrogen/Progestin Replacement Study (HERS) show no statistically
significant differences in heart disease between postmenopausal
women who do and do not take hormone replacement therapy.
The
action of sex steroid hormones on the brain is postulated as the
biological basis behind many gender differences in neurological
functioning, as the data on pain, mental abilities, neuromuscular
diseases, and addiction indicate. However, newer research is hinting
at gender differences not solely based on the action of sex steroids
or the fluctuations of the menstrual cycle. Men and women metabolize
food, alcohol, medications, and atmospheric toxins differently.
Basic biological sex differences affect the pharmacokinetic and
pharmacodynamic profiles of the multitude of drugs we use. Laboratory
and clinical research emerging in the past few years is showing
gender differences in virtually all areas of drug research. The
biological factors of drug abuse, the antecedents and consequences
of drug use and abuse, and prevention and treatment strategies
all show gender-based differences.
Sex steroid hormones appear to be of significant importance in
the prevalence of many mental disorders. Research is examining
gender-related differences in the mechanisms of neurotransmission
and the metabolism of neurotransmitters in the brain. In addition,
researchers are seeking to identify the genetic components of
major mental disorders. For example, it has been known for years
that women are 2-3 times more likely to suffer from depression
than men. Findings published in 1998 using PET imaging of human
brains shows that the average rate of serotonin synthesis is 52%
greater in male than in female subjects. This is "one of
the largest differences between brains in males and females that
is not related to hormone binding sites". Also "the
lower rate of serotonin synthesis in women may be related to the
higher incidence of unipolar depression".
Immunology is an area of striking gender differences. Women have
enhanced levels of immunoreactivity compared to men, which increases
womens resistance to many types of infection, but also makes
them more susceptible to autoimmune diseases. Women constitute
75% of those afflicted with autoimmune diseases. Womens
immunologic reactions to infectious disease have also been shown
to be different than mens. Rheumatoid arthritis is three
times more frequent in women than in men. Lupus disproportionately
affects young women of childbearing age, but the biological factors
that predispose women to the condition are unknown. Multiple sclerosis
(MS) is also more common in women, and the immune system plays
a strong role in this neuromuscular disorder.
The
recognition of gender as an important variable in scientific investigation
has grown among a variety of disciplines. However, for a multitude
of disease and conditions we may know only half of what we [need
to] because our knowledge is from male subjects only. In recent
years, an increasing number of requests for applications from
the federal government have been released in the area of gender-based
research. Additionally, a number of large private pharmaceutical
and research companies have begun investing in research and analyzing
gender differences in response to pharmaceuticals and other therapeutics.
Thompson
PM and Wolf JL. J. Inves. Med. 47:106-113, 1999.
Last modified:
August 13, 2003 |